Winchester Pocket Knife Review: What’s in a Name?

The Winchester pocket knife, and other knives like it, are great to have. They can be extremely useful both inside and outside of your house for various tasks. Finding a really good pocket knife is essential, however.

Back in 1919, a Winchester pocket knife represented true craftsmanship. However, the name Winchester was then and is still synonymous with firearms. As a matter of fact, Winchester’s tagline when they started producing knives was, “As good as the gun.” But are their knives as good as the gun?

Top 7 Winchester Pocket Knife Options

Below are some of the best of the Winchester pocket knife options available to you.

1. Winchester 22-41324 Brass Folding Knife

Here’s a handy little Winchester pocket knife that is the size of a Bic lighter when it’s folded, allowing it to fit neatly in your pocket. The namesake is etched onto the two-and-a-half-inch stainless steel blade as it is with most contemporary Winchester pocket knives.

This brass folding knife has wood overlays and polished brass plated bolsters. It’s a total of six inches long when opened and weighs just under two and a half ounces. The classic lock back system holds the blade in place when it’s closed, and a traditional nail nick in the blade is there to help open it back up.

Most customers on Amazon are happy with their purchase, rating the brass folding knife an average of 4.3 out of 5.0 stars.

Check Price

2. Winchester Pocket Knife, 31-000306

Bluegrass Cutlery discontinued the second Winchester pocket knife on our list, though it’s still for sale through some distributors on Amazon. Weighing close to four ounces, with a three-inch blade and a liner lock mechanism, this Winchester pocket knife has a total length of almost seven inches. It boasts a solid wooden handle and a clip for your pocket.

There are 183 reviews on Amazon, resulting in a 4.1 out of 5-star rating.

Check Price

3. Winchester 22-01335

Present-day Winchester brand pocket knives are all about the nostalgia of the name and the appearance of the product. In short, the knives are pretty. This Winchester pocket knife is no different in that respect. The wood inlay over stainless steel creates an elegant design that is further enhanced by the bronze-plated bolsters.

Another standout feature of this model is the three-inch serrated blade. The whole thing is four inches when you close it, making it a comfortable fit for your pocket. There are a limited number of reviews on Amazon for Winchester pocket knives as a whole. This model grabbed 44 customer reviews, giving it a total of 3.6 out of 5.0 stars.

Check Price

4. Gerber Winchester

This Gerber model pocket knife offers another option for a serrated blade. Winchester makes the knife out of surgical steel to guarantee that it won’t rust, and a smooth curve to fit nicely in your hand

The Gerber Winchester pocket knife is four inches when closed and extends to seven inches long. It has a liner lock, with a blade that’s just shy of three inches, and a bolster with wood inlay. There is also a pocket clip, and it comes with a limited lifetime warranty.

There aren’t many reviews on Amazon regarding this model. However, of the few that are there, they rate the Gerber version of the Winchester pocket knife a 4.7 out of 5.0 stars. That’s the best racing we’ve seen yet.

Customers who took the time to review this item were happy with its quality, style, and its looks. The serrated blade is a hit as well.

Check Price

5. Winchester Stockman Knife

Here’s a knife that is a little different from the other folding knives that we’ve reviewed thus far. It has three blades; two that are slightly shorter than two inches, and a third blade measuring just under three inches.

Another feature that makes this Winchester pocket knife stand out is its jagged bone handle. It has stainless steel blades and is reminiscent of the pocket knives we used as children to whittle sticks. It weighs a little over three ounces.

This little gem grabbed 4 out of 5.0 stars from 25 reviews on Amazon.

Check Price

6. A Cut Above Winchester Pocket Knives

There are many brands of pocket knives on the market today, but there is one that truly stands out. Buck is a family-owned business whose knives have been in production since 1902. Unlike Winchester, they continue to manufacture their pocket knives in the U.S. and even offer tours of the plant in Idaho.

As far as pocket knives go, the Buck 55 is comparable to the Winchester brass folding knife, the first pocket knife in our review. A big difference is in its price. This pocket knife will cost two to three times as much as the Winchester.

The Buck 55 pocket knife has a blade that’s just shy of three inches long and is right at four inches when you close it. It weighs less than two ounces and fits easily into your pocket. It is a smaller version of the Buck 110 and offers a wood grain handle, brass bolsters, and a 420HC stainless steel clip point blade.

There are far more reviews for Buck knives on Amazon than there are for Winchester. In particular, the Buck 55 has 373 customer reviews and garners 4.6 out of 5.0 stars. Pretty impressive compared to Winchester’s ratings.

Check Price

7. Buck Knives 303 Cadet

The last pocket knife in our review is a comparison to the Winchester Stockman knife. The Buck Cadet has three blades. As with the other Buck knife, this one is a bit more expensive than the Winchester, and also a better knife.

The Cadet features a two-and-a-half-inch clip blade, a Sheepsfoot blade that is just under two inches, and a Spey, also slightly less than two inches. The manufacturer makes the blades of 420HC steel. It weighs less than two ounces and is less than four inches long when closed. Buck’s Cadet is elegant as well, with a handle that boasts nickel silver bolsters.

Like the Buck 55, the Buck Cadet has far more reviews than its Winchester counterpart, which speaks volumes as far as which knives customers are purchasing. Of the 217 reviews, 82 percent of customers rated the Cadet at five stars, resulting in a total of 4.6 out of 5.0 stars.

Check Price

Winchester Brand

Winchester manufactured their own knives between 1919 and 1942 after they purchased the Eagle Knife Company. They kept the process that Eagle developed for assembly line production. The gun manufacturer also took over the New York-based Napanoch and incorporated that company’s blade grinding process to ensure that the quality of the knives they produced would stand up to the Winchester brand’s reputation. This high-quality artistry lasted until the 1930s when competition enticed Winchester to create lines that didn’t cost as much to make so that they could sell them at a lower price.

Those earliest knives are still out there, and they are, for the most part, collector’s items. So, if you own an old Winchester pocket knife, you may want to look into the manufacturing date. Today, the knives are produced by Bluegrass Cutlery, which was licensed in the 1980s to manufacture and distribute their knives under the Winchester brand name. Manufacturing takes place in China, and you can usually expect a lifetime warranty.

Price range

You’ll find all of the pocket knives that we’ve reviewed in this article on Amazon, in a price range from $10 to $100. You can purchase them at other online locations as well. Additionally, if you’re looking for a vintage Winchester pocket knife, check out eBay.

How We Reviewed

First, we looked into the history of Winchester pocket knives and discovered that they stopped producing the knives after World War II. Then we researched who currently manufactures knives under the Winchester brand. After that, we looked into where you can purchase a Winchester pocket knife and who sells a comparable product. Finally, we scoured Amazon to see if we could find some solid customer reviews.

What we found is that Winchester is still the go-to brand for firearms. But, there are many alternatives when it comes to pocket knives, and Winchester is by no means the leader in that arena.

Does Winchester Take a Slice out of the Competition?

No, not really. At this point, Winchester is a nostalgic name, not a good brand of the pocket knife. However, if that doesn’t bother you and you’re looking for a nice little pocket knife as a gift, or as a starter knife, then Winchester is a fine choice with a low price point. They also make various commemorative pocket knives that are good for a collection. If you want a real Winchester pocket knife, then you have to buy vintage and look for knives made before the 1940s.

If you want a knife that represents the manufacturer, then buy a Buck knife. Because, what Winchester is to rifles, Buck is to knives. And, Buck offers a lifetime guarantee. One more thing — if you’re ordering online, make sure you’re ordering from a reputable dealer.

Leave a Comment